By Anne Marie Ellis, Esq.
February 2019
I hope your 2019 is off to a good start! I have been tracking Prop. 65 filings this year, and it is evident that many of the usual products (general consumer products), chemicals (lead and phthalates), noticing parties and law firms are at play. However, it is apparent that there are a new crop of “noticing parties” and lawyers entering this arena, signaling that it is an area of rapid growth and profit for the plaintiff’s bar.
After researching the recently filed notices, I compiled a representative list of the most common products as set forth below. I still contend that noticing parties are reaching for the “lowest hanging fruit”- targeting low price point products that are easily bought in discount and big-box stores. If you sell consumer products that meet these criteria, you should insure compliance with Prop. 65 immediately. Aside from consumer products, there have been developments in the environmental exposure warnings that I will discuss below.
Representative Products and Noticing Parties
| Product |
Chemical |
Noticing Party |
| Acrylic Paint Set |
DEHP |
Anthony Ferreiro |
| Alcohol |
|
John Devlin |
| Artificial plant |
DINP |
Shefa LMV |
| Blending makeup sponge |
DEHP |
CAPA (Center for Advanced Public Awareness) AND Kawahito Law Group |
| Boxing gloves |
DEHP |
Ecological Alliance |
| Clam meat |
Lead |
Chemical Toxin Working Group |
| Clear Cross Body Bags with plastic components |
DEHP |
CAG (Consumer Advocacy Group) |
| Darice metal wire |
Lead |
APS&EE |
| Faux leather and vinyl fabric |
DEHP |
APS&EE |
| Foldable chair with polymer components |
DEHP |
CAG |
| Frying pans |
DEHP |
Ecological Alliance |
| Manicure and brush sets |
DEHP/DINP |
Ecological Alliance |
| Non-slip placemats |
DEHP |
CAPA |
| Over-the-door organizer |
DEHP |
Center for Advanced Public Awareness |
| Raw cacao |
Cadmium and cadmium components |
CAG |
| Reflective Sticker Packs |
DEHP |
Ecological Alliance |
| Seasoned laver |
Cadmium and cadmium components |
CAG |
| Shoe cleaning kit |
DEHP |
Ecological Alliance |
| Sink Mat |
DEHP |
CAPA |
| Tire gauges |
DEHP |
Ecological Alliance |
| Travel pouch with vinyl components |
DEHP |
CAG |
| Umbrella Cover |
DEHP |
Anthony Ferreiro |
| Women’s decorated plastic sandals |
DBP |
CAG |
“Test Case” in Environmental Exposure Warnings
I have uncovered a recently filed notice of violation that should serve as a cautionary tale to businesses with respect to environmental and occupational exposure warnings. An environmental exposure notice was filed on February 1, 2019 against a manufacturing company in Huntington Beach, alleging styrene exposures from plastics processing. The notice alleges that the violations have been occurring since April 2017 and the location of the exposure is the neighborhood surrounding a 0.1 mile radius of the facility. The noticing party claims that the facility’s operations release styrene into the air, exposing residents living and working within these limits to styrene, and that there is no clear and reasonable warning provided regarding the carcinogenic hazards of styrene. This notice is unique because it seeks to enforce a draconian warning requirement as it encompasses persons outside of the manufacturing company.
According to Title 27 Cal. Code of Regs. Article 6, § 25604 (the section applying to environmental exposures), businesses must warn at indoor and outdoor spaces with clearly defined entrances, with a sign in 72-font type or larger bearing the following language:
WARNING: Entering this area can expose you to chemicals known to the State of California to cause birth defects or other reproductive harm, including [name of one or more chemicals], from [name of one or more sources of exposure]. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.
The regulations state that the warning must be provided in a conspicuous manner and in a manner that is likely to be seen, read and understood by an ordinary individual in the course of normal daily activity. Crucially, the warning must also be provided in a notice that is mailed, sent electronically, or delivered to each occupant in the affected area. The notice must identify one or more sources of exposure, include a map that clearly identifies the affected area, be provided every 3 months, and can be published in the largest newspaper that is circulated in the area for which the warning is given. This is a significant burden for business, and one that has not regularly been tested by the typical notices of violation. If you own or operate physical locations within California, you should take this opportunity to consider whether such warnings are required, and to whom the warnings should be provided.
Upcoming Deadline – February 28, 2019
As a reminder, there is an upcoming deadline with which you must comply if applicable. If you are providing warnings to downstream retailers (in lieu of warning on the package or product), pursuant to Title 27 Cal. Code of Regs. Article 6, § 25600.2, the notice to the retailer must be renewed and receipt of the notice must be confirmed electronically or in writing by the retail seller’s authorized agent no later than February 28, 2019. Thereafter, the notice must be provided annually during the period in which the product is sold in California by the retail seller. If you add a different or additional chemical name or endpoint, an additional notice is required within 90 days of such change in the composition of the product. This section does not apply if you are placing a warning on the product and the retailer is simply selling the product with the label.
Anne Marie Ellis is Senior Counsel in Buchalter’s Products Liability Practice Group. She can be reached at [email protected] or 949.224.6223.
This alert is published as a service to our clients and friends. The material contained here is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute advertising, solicitation or legal advice. The views expressed herein are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Buchalter Nemer or its clients. For more information, visit www.buchalter.com.
